TOP 5 MASCARAS OUR BEAUTY SQUAD LOVES
Mascara is more than the final step in a makeup routine, it’s the product that instantly opens the eyes, lifts the face, and gives that main-character energy in seconds. But with hundreds of options on the market, finding the one that truly delivers can feel overwhelming.
So we asked the people who test, wear, and love beauty the most: our Beauty Squad 💖
From dramatic volume to sky-high length and everyday definition, these are the five mascaras our community keeps repurchasing, recommending, and reaching for on repeat. Whether you’re a luxury lover or a drugstore queen, this list has a lash hero for you.
1. Lancôme Lash Idole Mascara
The effortless, clean-girl lash with a luxury lift
If you love lashes that look naturally perfect (but better), this is your girl. Lash Idôle is all about that fanned-out, feathery, eye-opening effect — every lash separated, lifted and defined without heaviness or clumps. The curved wand with hundreds of micro-bristles grabs even the tiniest inner-corner lashes, giving a soft, fluttery result that lasts all day while feeling almost weightless.
Beauty Squad vibe: your everyday “my lashes but on their best behaviour” mascara.
Perfect for: natural glam, office days, clean makeup looks, short or straight lashes that need lift.
PRICE: €28.00
2. Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara
The viral length queen that never lets you down
This is the mascara our squad reaches for when we want unreal length on a real-life budget. It stretches the lashes vertically (like, how are they that long?), separates beautifully and stays lightweight, no crunchy feel, no droopy ends. It’s the closest thing to a lash-lift-in-a-tube and the fact that it performs like high-end formulas makes it a permanent repurchase.
Beauty Squad vibe: the TikTok-famous overachiever that actually deserves the hype.
Perfect for: short lashes, minimal makeup days, anyone who wants length over volume.
PRICE: €17.49
3. Benefit Roller Lash Mascara
The curl holder that gives doll-like definition
Think of this as your built-in lash curler. Roller Lash gives a wide-awake, lifted, perfectly separated curl that stays put for hours, even if your lashes normally drop. The result is super neat, glossy and fluttery, never messy or too dramatic.
Beauty Squad vibe: polished, pretty, and always reliable.
Perfect for: straight lashes, hooded eyes, soft glam lovers, bottom-lash definition.
PRICE: €31.05
4. Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara
The bold, dramatic, night-out icon
This is the one we grab when subtle is not the plan. Better Than Sex delivers thick, intense, full-body volume in one coat, with a lush, black finish that makes your eyes the main event. It stretches, curls and builds fast thanks to film-forming polymers that lock the shape in place.
Beauty Squad vibe: big hair, big lashes, main-character energy.
Perfect for: glam looks, sparse lashes, photos, nights out, maximum impact.
PRICE: €32.20
5. Nars Climax Mascara
The buildable volume for a soft-to-bold lash mood
Climax is the mascara for people who want control. One coat gives soft, fluffy definition — keep layering and you get rich, dramatic volume without stiffness. The formula stays flexible, so lashes feel plush and touchable, never crunchy.
Beauty Squad vibe: the customizable mascara that adapts to your mood.
Perfect for: day-to-night makeup, medium-to-long lashes, volume lovers who hate clumps.
PRICE: €32.20
Different lashes, different goals, but one thing is clear: a great mascara has the power to transform your entire look in seconds.
What makes these five stand out isn’t just the hype, it’s real results, real routines, and real repurchases from our Beauty Squad. From the cult-favourite drama of Too Faced Better Than Sex to the viral length of Maybelline Sky High, each one earns its place for a reason, whether that’s lift, separation, curl, or full-on volume. Industry testing and editor reviews consistently praise formulas like Lancôme Lash Idôle for clump-free lift and Maybelline Sky High for affordable, dramatic length, proving that performance exists at every price point.
The best mascara? The one that matches your lash mood and makes you feel instantly confident.
And if your makeup bag is ready for an upgrade… consider this your sign to try a new lash icon 👀✨
Have you tried any of these products? Head over to the Beauty Buddy app and add your review! Earn points that you can exchange for rewards. See you on the Beauty Buddy App! 😊🌟
More interesting blogs…
