The Line-Up: 5 Top-Rated Eyeliners Our Beauty Buddies Swear By
If there is one product that can sense your fear, it’s eyeliner. We’ve all been there: one minute you’re aiming for a subtle flick, and the next, you’re accidentally channeling a raccoon. Finding "The One"—the liner that doesn't skip, smudge, or fade by lunchtime—is a rite of passage for every beauty lover.
At Beauty Buddy, we don’t just look at the ads; we look at the real reviews from our community. Whether you have shaky hands, oily lids, or a passion for a 1960s cat-eye, these are the five eyeliners our Buddies consistently rate as "holy grail" material.
1. NYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink Liner
The Verdict: The "No-Nonsense" MVP.
If you want a wing so sharp it could cut glass, this is your weapon of choice. Our community loves the slender, supple brush tip (no stiff felt-tips here!) that follows the curve of your eye effortlessly. It’s intensely pigmented and famously waterproof.
Be warned, when they say waterproof, they mean it. This won't budge through a rainy commute or a sad movie, but you’ll definitely need an oil-based remover to say goodbye at the end of the night.
PRICE: €9.99
2. 3INA 24H Pen Eye Liner
The Verdict: The High-Fashion "One Swipe" Wonder.
3INA (pronounced Mee-Nah) has gained a cult following on the app for its incredible color payoff. This pen feels more expensive than it is, offering a weighted grip that gives you extra control. It dries down to a true matte finish that looks incredibly professional.
This is the liner for people who hate "patchy" black. It stays saturated with ink until the very last drop, so you aren't constantly shaking it mid-wing.
PRICE: €16,95
3. Rimmel Glam Eyeliner Liquid
The Verdict: The OG Precision Tool.
This is a classic "dip" liner with a micro-fine brush. Our Buddies with hooded eyes often recommend this because the formula dries almost instantly, preventing that dreaded "transfer" onto the upper lid.
Because the brush is so thin, it’s perfect for "tightlining" or adding just a tiny bit of definition to the lash line without looking like you’re wearing a heavy beat.
PRICE: €6.99
4. Rimmel Exaggerate Liquid Liner
The Verdict: The Reliable "Daily Driver."
The Exaggerate liner features a unique felt-tip applicator that’s slightly firmer than a brush, making it the perfect "training wheels" liner for beginners. It gives you a bold, slightly glossy finish that makes eyes pop.
This is our go-to for a "classic" look. It’s incredibly easy to control the thickness of the line just by changing the pressure. Plus, it’s usually at a price point that makes it a total steal.
PRICE: €5.99
5. NYX Professional Makeup Jumbo Eye Pencil
The Verdict: The Multi-Tasking Legend.
Not everyone wants a sharp liquid line. The Jumbo Pencil is a Beauty Buddy icon because it’s a liner and an eyeshadow in one. It glides on like butter (no tugging on the lids!) and blends out beautifully for a smoky, lived-in look.
Pro tip from the community, use the shade ‘Milk’ (the matte white) as a base under your colored eyeshadows to make the pigment absolutely scream. Just make sure to set it with powder so it doesn't crease!
PRICE: €6.00
Finding the perfect liner is a personal journey, but you don't have to walk it alone. Whether you’re a pro with the 3INA pen or a fan of the soft NYX Jumbo smudge, these top five picks have been tried, tested, and "Buddy-Approved." Next time you're standing in the beauty aisle, check your Beauty Buddy app to see how these stack up in real-time!
Have you tried any of these products? Head over to the Beauty Buddy app and add your review! Earn points that you can exchange for rewards. See you on the Beauty Buddy App! 😊🌟
More interesting blogs…
